Liquid Eyeliner Pen - Long Wearing & Smudge Proof Precision Eye Liner Pencil Tool with Super Slim Fine Point for Perfect Eye Makeup - Quick Drying Formula - Black by Mellow Cosmetics

This eye liner is amazing! I got it the first time in my Ipsy bag and I was skeptical because I’ve never found a liquid pen eyeliner that lasts longer than a couple weeks. It has been several months and it still works great. I only ordered a new one in anticipation that the old one would quit or I would have to toss it since you are supposed to toss eye products after so long. But the old one still goes on perfectly and it stays put. If you are hesitant to spend more than the Walmart price for eyeliner, just know that in the long run you will come out way ahead with this one.

Love this one !! I got it in a boxycharm and fell in love .. only one I use for sure !! It is a great black .. if you use eyeliner a lot you know there’s some that don’t seem black black lol .. stays on all night even bartending and sweating like crazy

Ever since I got the pen it's felt like and goes on like as if it is dried out. I have to lick the felt to get it to do anything and even then it goes on really light. Nothing like the pictures or description. I've used this brand before in an ipsy bag and this isn't how it was then...

So. I got this product in an Ipsy bag and used the heck out of it for 6 months straight and it never dried out. So naturally I decide to try to find and buy the product (got lucky with this inexpensive price). Not even a month into having it, and not wearing it every day, the thing is dried out!! It’s like it was already an old product when they sent it to me. Super disappointed because I’ve never found an eyeliner I truly loved. And now I’ll have to find something else.

This is hands down the best eyeliner that I have ever purchased! Glides on easily and stays in place!

This product works the way you would hope other eyeliners could work!! Excellent product

I have trouble with water eyes and this isn't perfect for me but it's the best I've found! Not 100% waterproof but definitely water resistant.

I have to add water to the felt tip so that it goes on. Otherwise, it’s dry and won’t work. Too bad because I do like the felt tip applicator. It’s just not a great product.