The Wrong Family: A Domestic Thriller

SPOILER-FREE REVIEW: The Wrong Family was written by author Tarryn Fisher, whose recent novel The Wives was a NYT bestseller and a Book of the Month pick for December 2019. The Wrong Family was published on December 29th, 2020 by Graydon House (in trade paperback format), with this glowing endorsement from NYT bestselling romance/thriller author Colleen Hoover: “The Wrong Family is your new obsession...you’ve never read anything like this.” The tagline of the novel reads, “A lifetime of deadly secrets, all under one roof.” (8/10 stars)PLOT RUNDOWN/BASICS: Everyone in this novel has secrets: Winnie, the high-strung wife whose money came from her father’s untimely death, and who bought her dream house without bothering to seek her husband’s input or approval. Nigel, who seems to stay with Winnie more out of obligation than affection, even as he cleans up after their fights and comes home to her every day. Their teenage son Sam, who writes secret blog entries musing about whether he was adopted, and researches living on the street. And Juno, who recently moved in with the Crouch family after living on the streets for years, and has a secret past of her own.Juno can’t help but overhear Winnie and Nigel’s arguments, and as she learns more about their pasts, she falls back into an old bad habit of her own: snooping with the intention of interfering in someone else’s life. At the same time, Winnie starts receiving messages and finding clues that someone in her own life has discovered her darkest secret - and is going to use it against her, even as everything else around her starts to fall apart.Juno’s and Winnie’s lives are on a collision course, as unexpected secrets are revealed and dangerous threats are overlooked in their attempts to right the ship. Will the truths all come to light, or will more secrets be the answer to preserving everything they thought they wanted? And who will live to tell the tale when all is said and done?MY THOUGHTS: This was my second book by Tarryn Fisher; I read The Wives in 2019 and enjoyed it, but the premise of this one was much more intriguing to me. I finished it in one day, so it’s safe to say that I found it to be an easy read. This is a dark story with a realistic ending, which is right up my alley - but if you’re on the fence, I’ll go into more detail below.I’m going to go out on a limb and assume that the situation/secret of Juno’s - I can't say more without possibly spoiling it for readers - is supposed to be a surprise until the end of part one (page 91 of 302), but to me it was very clear from page one what was actually happening. Nevertheless, I made myself promise to read the first 100 pages to see if there was more to this story than the eventual “reveal” - and I was NOT disappointed. If you know this truth from the start, don’t worry - you haven’t figured out the plot itself. You’re still in for a very layered and dynamic mystery story that doesn’t follow an “easy” contemporary thriller formula.Fisher refers to herself as a writer “of villains,” and while I can't argue with her own self-assessment, I think she’s just very in-touch with the darker side of humanity. Everyone in this novel has a “villainous” side, as it were, just as we all have the capability of hurting those closest to us. Whether it’s keeping your own deadly secrets (or someone else’s), or actively manipulating another person’s life - not to mention the cheating, or alcoholism, or stealing - each character grapples with their own demons and finds ways (sometimes neutral, sometimes terrible) of dealing with them.Some of us may connect a little too deeply with Fisher’s depiction of the reality of having someone who grapples with mental illness in our families. She unabashedly explores how family can, at its worst, enable and overlook the dangers of a family member battling a very real and serious mental illness. In fact, many of the situations in the novel could be rectified if the person going through it would stop seeking to find a quick-fix that gives peace and satisfaction immediately, versus confronting the reality of the situation head-on and working through it - even with pain and discomfort and loss - to find an actual long-term solution. Instead, we slap a band-aid on it and move on...and in certain cases, this has deadly consequences.Lest I point out only the “heaviness” of the novel’s dark themes, I would like to emphasize how easy-to-read I found this book. It has twists and turns I wasn’t expecting, which always makes me incredibly happy (especially after thinking I’d guessed the major plot point on page one). It also bounces back and forth between the perspectives of Juno and Winnie, as we learn their past struggles and what led them to the spiraling situations they currently find themselves in.Fisher doesn’t give us a neat thriller with a happy ending for everyone; in fact, I’m not convinced she believes in happy endings (at least for her thrillers). She writes a much more realistic, brutal, confrontational-yet-satisfying ending that provides the reader with a clear idea of the consequences of each character’s actions...whether they be equal to, or greater than, the choices that led each person to their reckoning. I am 100% for this type of story and its ending, and I will absolutely be reaching for the next Fisher novel. But if happy endings are your thing…….maybe skip this one.

This is the second book I’ve read by this author, although it was totally different from her other work, The Wives.Juno is a homeless older woman living in a Seattle park. Since she grieves the loss of her own family, home and career, she has been watching the Crouch family. They live in one of the grander homes overlooking the park, and Juno becomes very fixated on their daily lives. One day she sneaks into their home through an addition and doesn’t leave, hiding in the crawl space. Being a voyeur in the home, she soon learns that things are never as perfect as they seem. This family has its secrets too.I liked the plot and enjoyed the story, especially the second half. This author can be a little confusing because she throws in a lot of random characters and names, some that have very little to do with the story. That can be a little distracting. It also seemed to me that Winnie Crouch could have saved herself years of guilt and problems by just being truthful at the beginning. What she did wasn’t that horrible given the circumstances. The reader is mislead through most of this book, which was okay, but didn’t make complete sense once the real secret was revealed.I couldn’t understand why this was a thriller until the ending. It was more like a psychological profile of a dysfunctional family putting on appearances. However, I liked the ending, which was action packed. I enjoy this author, and I will read her again!

This book is definitely one that is different from any I've read before. It has a unique premise and a cast of characters that are both familiar in some ways and, hopefully, unfamiliar in even more ways. Since there are already a lot of reviews that recap the the story extremely well I'll go right into the review part, which will probably have a bit of recap in it anyway we'll see when the words appear.There are things about this book that I liked quite a bit and things that I disliked equally as much. This is a really slow going story. It's got a whole lot of building up to things. So much so it does seem to get almost boring. It's not so much the build up where you learn your characters and the story line and so on because, well, you need those things it's just that it stalls a bit and takes a really long time to get the point across. Now I like story time and lots of words but this one just felt almost tedious at times. When the end came around, parts of it were terrific and some parts not so much but that's not unusual.All that said, what I did like about it was how when things did click together they really clicked together. When you found out why people were reacting the way they were or doing the things they were it all made a lot of sense. The characters were well written in that they were well defined by their characteristics. You knew why they were the way they were and how they came to be that way. I know this review is scattered and detail-less but I don't want to give out spoilers, especially with a thriller.The author is a terrific writer so the writing is great quality, the story just had some issues, if all that makes sense. Would I recommend this one? I would. I think you need to see for yourself how you feel about this book.

Great read....it was a bit slow but the ending was excellent.

There are no plot twists with every turn of the page, which is what the book’s publicity blurb promises until the reader is 72% through the book. A waste of time and money reading this one.

Das Buch ist spannend, wenn das Ende auch etwas abrupt. Es liest sich flüssig und die Story ist sehr gut geplant.

I have no words for this story, I'm in awe of this author and the way her incredible brain works to think up these unusual creative plots for the books she writes, as far as I am concerned the women is a genius with an imagination like no other and yet she draws from real life experiences that could happen to us all maybe one day.The writing is wonderful, the characters amazing, flawed, real, sad, honest and the story - well for me it was everything and more. I couldn't have guessed what was going to happen in a million years and that is what is so good about this book. I loved that Tarryn Fisher dealt with the problems we see around us all the time; homelessness was a massive deal in this book and hit my heart hard. Mental illness was another subject dealt with, boredom, restlessness, every day issues that effect someone you may know or even yourself. Yes, real life situations until they are not so everyday anymore and then it hits you like a punch in the face. This is what this author does best. I love how she doesn't always give you what you would maybe expect or like at the end of a book, flowers and roses maybe, HEA's - don't hold your breathe because this story will take you on the ride of your life. Angsty beyond belief, extremely sad in parts, at least it was for me and shocking a lot of the time too.I loved it so much.When I hear Tarryn Fisher is bringing a new book out I'm like a kid in a sweet store. I cannot wait to devour the twisty savoury sweet darkness that is Tarryn Fisher's mind until she has my head in a spin. This is one of those books when you close the last page quietly, look up and around you and say "F*** what did I just read !! An absolute gem of a book you won't want to miss. Perfection!!

Loved the plot twists in this one had me fairly hooked from the start and was fairly fast paced. Really enjoyed reading this book and highly recommend